The “symphonic” approach initiated by the Moody Blues and developed by Genesis, Yes and ELP was drastically shifted with the new wave of sound and meaning of “progressive” rock. Phil Collins had such a different frontman demeanour than Peter Gabriel that I suppose they had no choice but to change their entire direction if they were to remain together. I always thought that PG Genesis would be one of the “Prog” bands from the Golden Age that would stand the most revisiting. Lately, though, as I am listening to their classic stuff I've been mostly impressed (sadly) by how diatonic and sing-songy so much of it is. This brings me to the era of Krautrock and Pink Floyd. They hit the stage with bursting flames and added new dimensions under the genre of progressive rock that had not been discovered before. Krautrock was capable of being quite horrifying and dark. Although, this was by no means a rule for the newly transformed genre. If Krautrock had been only horrifying music, it would have been indistinguishable from the post countercultural rock previously discussed through the course. Hovering
moogs and hyper-distorted guitars come to crush the world of Rock, as we are also given a few rays of hope with Krautrock. Einstuerzende Neubauten once said, “Destruction is not negative, you must destroy to build”, which is in itself the essence of Krautrock. Another aspect to Krautrock is the use of minimalistic or very simple melodies. A quick listen to Faust's "Krautrock" will reveal that the melody is in fact childishly simple, but as elsewhere, this very simple idea is extended to its absolute limits (12 minutes), and is at no point disappointing. Hence, Krautrock often seems very much free of the egos that dominate most of rock and roll vibe that took over in the early 70’s. "Krautrock”, seems to be generally recognized as music which appeared mainly on the Ohr, Pilz and Cosmic Couriers labels. "Krautrock" also implies to me a fairly narrow time frame, from about late 1968 to
the middle of 1973. Also during this time, Pink Floyd rarely indulged in the show-off polymeric twaddle practiced by bands like Genesis or Yes. Genesis' Dance on a Volcano made perfect for the theme which genuinely makes some queasy, with the melodic phrase feeling unfinished on the end beats. The follwiing beat hangs in mid-air without function and induces an unpleasant vertigo sensation. It's completely unnecessary because, if they had continued the stress set up by the other notes of the melody, the flow of this phrase would have naturally formed. The only notable song where the Floyd lapse into an unusual metre is Money, which was one of their most commercially successful songs. They could do wacky time signatures if they fancied. Band member, Rick Wright was the most traditionally tutored musician in the Floyd and the other band members often spoke of the jazz influence he brought to the group. However, the most remarkable thing about Rick is how he let himself be molded by the experimental tendencies of Syd Barrett and Roger Waters. It is testament to his sympathetic and sensitive ability that I rarely hear a jazz influence in Floyd more specifically Rick’s work. His best known, the headache-inducing/soothing Great Gig in the Sky, contains jazzy chords, but is really just a series of beautiful chord progressions, and not jazz in any meaningful way or at least how I think of jazz. Too often, “prog” rock is about nicking half-baked ideas from genuinely progressive music and executing them poorly or so at times I think so. Pink Floyd and the Krautrock era were strangely detached from the progressive rock we had been acquainted with. The intensely moving; bleak but heartfelt lyrics and music and overall theme through bands such as these changes and added to the already unique “progressive’ rock era that was continually changing.
moogs and hyper-distorted guitars come to crush the world of Rock, as we are also given a few rays of hope with Krautrock. Einstuerzende Neubauten once said, “Destruction is not negative, you must destroy to build”, which is in itself the essence of Krautrock. Another aspect to Krautrock is the use of minimalistic or very simple melodies. A quick listen to Faust's "Krautrock" will reveal that the melody is in fact childishly simple, but as elsewhere, this very simple idea is extended to its absolute limits (12 minutes), and is at no point disappointing. Hence, Krautrock often seems very much free of the egos that dominate most of rock and roll vibe that took over in the early 70’s. "Krautrock”, seems to be generally recognized as music which appeared mainly on the Ohr, Pilz and Cosmic Couriers labels. "Krautrock" also implies to me a fairly narrow time frame, from about late 1968 to
the middle of 1973. Also during this time, Pink Floyd rarely indulged in the show-off polymeric twaddle practiced by bands like Genesis or Yes. Genesis' Dance on a Volcano made perfect for the theme which genuinely makes some queasy, with the melodic phrase feeling unfinished on the end beats. The follwiing beat hangs in mid-air without function and induces an unpleasant vertigo sensation. It's completely unnecessary because, if they had continued the stress set up by the other notes of the melody, the flow of this phrase would have naturally formed. The only notable song where the Floyd lapse into an unusual metre is Money, which was one of their most commercially successful songs. They could do wacky time signatures if they fancied. Band member, Rick Wright was the most traditionally tutored musician in the Floyd and the other band members often spoke of the jazz influence he brought to the group. However, the most remarkable thing about Rick is how he let himself be molded by the experimental tendencies of Syd Barrett and Roger Waters. It is testament to his sympathetic and sensitive ability that I rarely hear a jazz influence in Floyd more specifically Rick’s work. His best known, the headache-inducing/soothing Great Gig in the Sky, contains jazzy chords, but is really just a series of beautiful chord progressions, and not jazz in any meaningful way or at least how I think of jazz. Too often, “prog” rock is about nicking half-baked ideas from genuinely progressive music and executing them poorly or so at times I think so. Pink Floyd and the Krautrock era were strangely detached from the progressive rock we had been acquainted with. The intensely moving; bleak but heartfelt lyrics and music and overall theme through bands such as these changes and added to the already unique “progressive’ rock era that was continually changing.